This review of Baby Reindeer opened with a confession plenty of readers will recognise: “I am not one to binge-watch TV shows, but I find watching several films throughout the week difficult these days.” The hard part was choosing.
Spotify says it now carries over 100 million tracks, and most of the work its home screen does is hiding that number behind a few rows. Online casinos reached the same problem later, and spent most of the last decade competing on how big the library was rather than on how anyone was supposed to find their way round it.
What Goes First
A page with hundreds of games still has to start somewhere, and whatever sits at the top gets most of the views. Take a major platform like Betway online casino, a renowned gaming site that welcomes users with two rows before anything else: Top Games, showing real-time player volume, and New Games, highlighting recent additions.
Those are two different sorting rules: popularity and recency. Top Games points a newcomer at what other people chose, which is also how a popular game stays popular, and New Games at whatever was added most recently. Matching a game to a mood is still left to whoever is scrolling.
What the Jam Stall Found
The best-known evidence that more choice can mean less of a decision came from a supermarket in Menlo Park. In a study published in 2000, Sheena Iyengar and Mark Lepper set up a tasting stall offering either six jams or twenty-four. The big display drew more people, 60 per cent of passers-by against 40, and sold far less: about 30 per cent of the six-jam shoppers bought a jar, against 3 per cent of those who’d faced twenty-four.
Later work was less kind to it. When Benjamin Scheibehenne and two colleagues pooled fifty experiments a decade later, they found “a mean effect size of virtually zero”, with overload showing up mainly when people didn’t already know what they wanted. For a casino site, that points at one visitor in particular: the regular who opens the same blackjack table every Friday copes fine with five hundred alternatives, and the person who arrived without a plan may not.
Streaming services learned how short that patience is. Two Netflix engineers wrote in 2015 that a typical member “loses interest after perhaps 60 to 90 seconds of choosing”, having looked at 10 to 20 titles.
Slots, Tables and Wheels
Those visitors don’t want the same evening either. Some want a slot, which asks very little between spins. Others want blackjack, with a decision on every card, or a roulette wheel at a live table that runs at the dealer’s pace, which suits some people and drives others mad. A front page built only on what’s popular will keep showing a blackjack regular a carousel of fishing-themed reels.
The Gambling Commission’s figures for the first three months of this year show how short the typical slot session has become. The largest online operators logged 202 million slot sessions, up 18 per cent on a year earlier, with the average session down to 15 minutes and about 4.4 per cent running past an hour, though the regulator notes that some firms changed how they count sessions.
Engagement Without the Stopwatch
If a typical session lasts a quarter of an hour before someone goes off to do something else, a site that measures success by keeping people longer is working against the way its own customers already behave.
The fixes are mostly unglamorous. Limits should be easy to set and hard to forget, a time-out should sit a tap away from the cashier rather than three menus under it, and each game’s rules, return to player included, should be readable before anyone deposits.


